Harsh J

Memoirs of a QWERTY Keyboard

Harry Potter

24 comments

Harry Potter

Saw the movie today and it was very very good. In fact so good that I came out disappointed. But then, all Harry Potter movies except for the first have done that to you, or a few of you anyway. The few being the ones who’ve read the book.

I won’t go on and on about how bad they’ve executed it, but let me just tell this. A Fred and George product shown in the movie, is next shown (nearly similar) to be used by Voldemort in his fight against Dumbeldore. Heh, that was the only part I smiled at :P

People going to watch it anyhow better find something to do in the first half, cause its gonna be one long and slow ride till the intermission. Am pretty sure almost all the book readers aren’t gonna like the way they’ve changed things in the movie. Agreed its got to be shorter but the critical magical elements like the Fountain, for example, was missed. And Fred and George’s escape could have been a lot better than just fireworks and that little something Voldemort copies later. :twisted:

Dumbeldore’s escape wasn’t as cool as described in the book, either. Alright, I’ll stop, go watch and enjoy. :)

Written by Harsh

July 16th, 2007 at 9:27 pm

Posted in Books,Fun,Movie,Personal

Tagged with

24 Responses to 'Harry Potter'

Subscribe to comments with RSS or TrackBack to 'Harry Potter'.

  1. OMG! The characters are showing me their fingers! :(

    Harsh

    16 Jul 07 at 9:28 pm

  2. i am going to watch the movie on thursday, coz i have school off that day. i am not exppecting too much from the movie, as the I have read the book (it always happens, and the movies have disappointing in a way, because they change critical factors.)

    thegreateye

    16 Jul 07 at 9:34 pm

  3. A trend that’s been very visible from the past two movies: Dobby and Neville. Neville always replaces Dobby’s act of good against his rules.

    Harsh

    16 Jul 07 at 9:37 pm

  4. I forgive you Harsh , reply or not , I’ll be visiting here regularly. The 2nd movie was bearable actually , but after the 3rd , all the movies have mutialted the story…
    I’m waiting for Deathly Hallows…
    Oh and you are a spidey fan rite , then go here http://gg-game.com/forum/viewthread.php?tid=34813&pid=416631&page=1&extra=page%3D1#pid416631
    zAp.RiSiNg is my id there…
    Do tell me how it is , and I’d love it if I saw one of your comments back at my blog.

    teen

    16 Jul 07 at 10:15 pm

  5. Damn movie directors , how could they leave out the FOUNTAIN!!!!

    teen

    16 Jul 07 at 10:16 pm

  6. Oye , and I’m using Open DNS , it’s amazing… I just love the level of control..

    teen

    17 Jul 07 at 12:34 am

  7. Glad to know that you like it too :)

    Harsh

    17 Jul 07 at 12:39 am

  8. You mean Open DNS , don’t you ? Coz’ i’ve made it a point to hate all HP movies after I saw the horrendous HP PoA movie.

    teen

    17 Jul 07 at 2:05 am

  9. of course , exceptions being the 1st and 2nd movie

    teen

    17 Jul 07 at 2:06 am

  10. Maybe Voldemort is the best customer of Fred and George :P

    Anyways its a sad thing Fred and George’s rebellion has been reduced to fireworks.

    Well am yet to see it….

    Beta3

    17 Jul 07 at 6:55 am

  11. I’m going to the movie this Thursday or Friday. It’s released a week late here in the UAE. We should not compare the book and the movie. The book is bound to be way better, we all see the movie because:

    - It’s a potter movie
    - want to see the scenes that we imagined
    - emma!

    :D

    Ashwin

    17 Jul 07 at 9:28 am

  12. Hmm… going to watch it on sunday morning since my sister wants to see it too.

    I actually didnt like this book personally very much so thought maybe if they included the best from the book it could have been the best movie. Last movie was crap I know but I just see these movies to see how much did they deviate from the books.

    Karthiksn

    17 Jul 07 at 11:24 am

  13. @Ashwin – The 2nd and 3rd Points are gonna be the major disappointment, really.

    @Karthik – That’s one hell of a reason to watch the movie! :P

    Harsh

    17 Jul 07 at 4:51 pm

  14. I too wrote review of it , where was Emma in the film ? , sigh ,I am sure , Ashwin gonna jump in hall or may be sleep ,LoL.

    rahul

    17 Jul 07 at 7:59 pm

  15. Watched it !!

    NOT entertaining at all :(

    Preshit

    17 Jul 07 at 11:59 pm

  16. Oh man boring at the beginning? I am going to sleep for sure. I cannot stand when they try to catch people up to the current status of whatever. Takes forever.

    Wengistein

    18 Jul 07 at 11:08 am

  17. My instincts were right about this movie too !!!
    They can never make a HP film which will be even half as good as the book !!!

    Vishnu

    18 Jul 07 at 5:21 pm

  18. but its much better than any of the previous movies

    ~~Shwetz~~

    18 Jul 07 at 8:07 pm

  19. @~~Shwetz~~ – :shock:

    Harsh

    18 Jul 07 at 8:55 pm

  20. @~~Shwetz~~ – :shock: too

    Preshit

    18 Jul 07 at 9:42 pm

  21. having been disappointed greatly after seeing GoF, the expectations I had for this movie were “none”. And am glad it lived upto it……

    the things that felt good while reading were not even filmed I think..

    the movies never feel [or rather have felt] as good as the books.. waiting eagerly for the release of “Deathly Hallows”

    Grace

    19 Jul 07 at 3:45 pm

  22. it’s not really that bad. i liked the pace of the movie. the initial 200 pages of the book were not really that good. i found the first half bearable and the second half electrifying. i have completely forgotten the book, so i cant compare with the movie. anywayz, all potter movies are worth a watch at least once.

    one thing i found funny abt the movie…where were the main characters? they were barely noticeable…

    thegreateye

    20 Jul 07 at 9:32 pm

  23. And all the ghosts were banned from Hogwarts? And the house points? Who wins the house competition?

    Harsh

    20 Jul 07 at 9:42 pm

  24. Well if they made the movie of the whole book then we would have been sitting there for more than 5 hours I guess.

    Karthiksn

    26 Jul 07 at 6:33 pm

Leave a Reply